Empowering Security in the AI Era: Insights from the 2025 ADVsec CISO Survey

The era of artificial intelligence is no longer just on the horizon—it’s reshaping security priorities and risk strategies at the highest levels. In our latest 2025 ADVsec CISO Survey, we gathered input from over 110 security leaders at major enterprises worldwide. Here we unpack the top findings, offer expert analysis, and deliver practical checklists to help you stay ahead in an AI-native landscape.

1. The AI Threat Landscape Is Already Here

Key Findings:

• 1 in 4 CISOs experienced an AI-generated attack in the past year.
• Many attacks mimic legitimate user behavior, making them hard to detect with traditional tools.

Case Study: AI-Driven Phishing at a Global Manufacturer

An ADVsec client in manufacturing saw a spike in targeted emails crafted by AI bots that replicated executive writing styles. Over a series of weeks, attackers used social engineering to harvest credentials.

Practical Prevention:

• Implement behavioral analytics to track time-to-exploitation and request velocity.
• Use AI-based anomaly detection alongside traditional SIEM.
• Conduct regular phishing simulations and employee training focused on AI-crafted messages.

Security Checklist:

1. Enable AI-driven threat detection engines.
2. Monitor for speed anomalies in login attempts and data exfiltration.
3. Schedule quarterly red-team exercises simulating AI threats.

2. AI Risk Tops the 2025 Priority List

Survey Insights:

• 37% rank securing AI agents as their #1 concern.
• 36% prioritize governing employee use of AI tools.

Expert Analysis

AI governance frameworks are still maturing. Without clear policies, shadow AI usage proliferates, exposing sensitive data.

Action Plan:

• Define an AI Acceptable Use Policy (AUP).
• Integrate AI tool usage into your existing Data Loss Prevention (DLP) controls.
• Establish a cross-functional AI risk governance committee.

Quick Wins:

• Deploy allowlists for vetted AI services.
• Require data sanitization before external AI calls.
• Track AI usage metrics and report monthly to the board.

3. Balancing Innovation and Control

Nearly 50% of organizations still restrict or allow-list AI tools—even amid strong business pressure to adopt them.

Recommendation:

• Implement a pilot program for new AI services, with security gates at each stage.
• Use tools that centralize AI access and enforce policy at the API layer.
• Educate employees on approved AI workflows and risks.

Deployment Checklist:

• [ ] Inventory current AI tools and shadow usage.
• [ ] Define roles and responsibilities for AI tool approvals.
• [ ] Automate policy enforcement via CASB or equivalent solutions.

4. The SOC’s AI-First Disruption

• 77% of CISOs believe SOC analysts will be the first to be replaced or augmented by AI.
• Automation is targeted at:
• Penetration testing (27%)
• Third-party risk assessments (27%)
• Identity provisioning and access reviews (24%)
• Threat modeling (22%)

Strategic Guidance

• Reskill SOC teams to manage and validate AI-driven alerts rather than manually triaging every event.
• Adopt a human-in-the-loop model that combines AI speed with expert judgment.

Training Roadmap:

1. Introduce AI alert validation workshops.
2. Establish AI tool certification for senior analysts.
3. Rotate analysts through AI governance roles to build trust in automated systems.

5. Best-of-Breed Solutions Make a Comeback

• 60% of CISOs now favor specialized point solutions over all-in-one platforms.

Why It Matters: CISOs demand demonstrable ROI and will not trade off solution quality for marginal cost savings.

Selection Criteria:

• Evaluate total cost of ownership (TCO) over a 3-year horizon.
• Assess integration capabilities via APIs or native connectors.
• Validate vendor roadmaps for AI and threat intelligence enhancements.

6. Budget Growth Slows, ROI Demands Rise

• 52% of survey respondents report a budget increase for 2025—down from 70% in 2024.

Implications for Vendors and Security Teams:

• Build clear business cases that link security investments to risk reduction metrics.
• Highlight time-to-value in proposals and demos.

Budget Optimization Tips:

• Consolidate overlapping tools and reallocate savings to AI risk initiatives.
• Use pilot programs with defined KPIs to secure incremental funding.

7. Vulnerability Management Still Faces Challenges

• 40% of critical vulnerabilities remain unpatched past SLA.
• Top blockers: Headcount shortages (62%) and legacy systems (32%).

Resolution Strategies:

• Implement automated patch orchestration for high-risk assets.
• Leverage asset discovery tools to maintain an accurate inventory.
• Prioritize patches using risk-based scoring rather than CVSS alone.

Operational Checklist:

1. Run daily vulnerability scans.
2. Use automated workflows to assign tickets based on severity.
3. Review patch backlog weekly and escalate stalled items.

8. Product Security Moves Center Stage

• 50% of CISOs are adopting a broad product security model.
• 36% have built dedicated programs.
• 23% plan to do so by 2026.

Focus Areas:

• Business logic flaws (37%)
• Privacy and data leakage (20%)
• Design vulnerabilities (20%)

Program Blueprint:

1. Embed security architects in each development squad.
2. Integrate threat modeling into design sprints.
3. Automate code analysis and run privacy checks in CI/CD pipelines.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The 2025 ADVsec CISO Survey underscores a fundamental shift: AI is no longer theoretical—it demands proactive security transformation. By adopting best practices, modernizing SOC operations, and reinforcing governance, security leaders can turn AI from a risk driver into a strategic advantage.

ADVsec is dedicated to empowering security teams for the AI era. For personalized guidance, contact an ADVsec employee.

‍